Mexico City has taken a significant step by banning traditional bullfighting and introducing a non-violent version, a decision celebrated by animal rights advocates. This change marks a new chapter in the ongoing efforts to end bullfighting in the city.
The city's congress voted to replace the traditional, violent bullfights with a bloodless alternative. Although this falls short of the complete ban activists have long sought, it is seen as progress. Anton Aguilar, head of Humane World for Animals Mexico, expressed relief that bulls will no longer endure the cruelty of being stabbed and killed in the ring. However, he cautioned that even without violence, these events might still cause suffering.
Plaza México, the largest bullfighting arena globally with 42,000 seats, will continue to host bullfights, but without the bloodshed. Matadors will use only capes to engage the bulls, and the animals' horns will be protected to prevent injuries. These events will be limited to 15 minutes, after which the bulls will return to their owners, ensuring they are not killed inside or outside the arena.
This initiative originated from a citizens' proposal for a complete ban, which was modified by Mexico City's government leader, Clara Brugada, to allow non-violent bullfights. Brugada argued that this approach preserves the economic benefits of bullfighting, which supports many jobs. She emphasized that while traditions are important, they must evolve, and animal welfare is a societal obligation.
Mexico's president, Claudia Sheinbaum, also endorsed the initiative. However, the bullfighting industry opposed the new rules, claiming they were not consulted. Salvador Arias, a lawyer for Tauromaquia Mexicana, criticized the proposal, comparing it to a failed attempt in Spain's Balearic Islands that did not attract much interest.
Animal rights groups hope that the lack of interest will lead to the decline of these events. Culture Without Torture expressed disappointment that the ban wasn't comprehensive but doubted the new format would appeal to traditional bullfighting fans who seek the spectacle of blood.