Republicans have formally blocked Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer's request to temporarily replace Senator Dianne Feinstein on the Judiciary Committee. Democrats aimed to make this change to advance judicial nominations that have been stalled. Feinstein, who is recovering from shingles, remains absent, prompting Democrats to seek a temporary replacement on the influential committee responsible for processing judicial nominees.
Republicans have been clear about their intention to prevent Democrats from replacing Feinstein, increasing the pressure on the 89-year-old senator to either resign or return swiftly. Feinstein's return date is uncertain, and she recently requested a temporary replacement while she recovers.
Schumer, speaking as both a leader and Feinstein's friend, introduced the motion, acknowledging her achievements. However, GOP Senator Lindsey Graham, the leading Republican on the Judiciary Committee, objected to Schumer's proposal, suggesting it was primarily about confirming more judges. Despite expressing well wishes for Feinstein's recovery, Graham argued that the move was politically motivated.
Democrats could still attempt to force a vote to replace Feinstein, but this would require the backing of 10 Republicans, a prospect that seems unlikely given the limited floor time available for such efforts. Feinstein, who has announced she will not seek reelection, initially planned to return by the end of March, but her return has been delayed due to ongoing health complications. She intends to return as soon as her medical team deems it safe.
Senator Ben Cardin mentioned discussions with Schumer about temporarily taking Feinstein's place on the committee, though he hasn't spoken with Feinstein herself. Cardin views this as a necessary step to continue committee business.
To replace Feinstein on the panel, Democrats need 60 votes, but senior Republicans have indicated they will not provide the necessary support. If Feinstein does not return soon, numerous judicial nominees could remain stalled, potentially hindering key Democratic initiatives.
When asked about the possibility of Feinstein resigning if she cannot return by May, Schumer expressed optimism about her imminent return. Feinstein announced in February that she would not run for reelection, leading to a competitive primary race for her seat in 2024. While many Democrats support her decision to stay in office during her recovery, some House Democrats have called for her resignation, a sentiment that could grow if her committee replacement is not secured.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Dick Durbin acknowledged that Feinstein's absence has slowed the confirmation of nominees but stopped short of calling for her resignation. He hopes Republicans will agree to a temporary replacement, recognizing that challenges can affect both parties.
Republican Senator John Cornyn, a senior Judiciary Committee member, opposes replacing Feinstein on the panel, stating that Republicans should not assist in confirming President Biden's controversial nominees. He supports Feinstein's return but does not anticipate Republican cooperation in confirming nominees he views as unqualified.